paula's cakeI should have taken a picture (dang!) but Brendan asked for Red Velvet cake for his birthday but asked if it could be blue. Actually blue-green is his very favorite color, so that is what I did! It came out great (I was afraid maybe the grey-brown of the cocoa in the cake might not bend to the blue-green dye's will but it did).
In fact, it was very pretty. It looked a lot like the one pictured above (Paula Deen's cake) but mine was more vibrant, more "turquoise".
That was for the "kid" party. Eight boys counting Brendan at our house. They LOVED the cake (it isn't that different from the one I make each year for birthdays, my buttermilk white cake --from Better Homes and Garden cookbook). For our "family" party, I made the classic Red Velvet cake. Most everyone loved it.
Buttermilk makes cakes extra tender. And the Red Velvet recipe calls for a small amount of cocoa and vinegar-baking soda which fizzes when you mix it...I think it gives the batter an oomph and causes the baking cake to rise a little more and be lighter, so you get a higher more tender cake. I have heard it is added to enhance the 'redness' of the cake too.
Anyway, there is nothing like the homemade red (or blue) velvet cake. And I make the real frosting too, which is a classic white sauce added to butter and sugar (oh MAMA). Some people use cream cheese, and that is fine, but not really authentic. Plus, it's almost too much with the sweet, light cake. The thing about the 'roux' frosting is it is not thick and it is very creamy.
Unfortunately, I have become famous for this cake and must make it often for people's birthdays:-). I actually love to delight people with it because most people only have it "out".
Once you make it a few times, it is easy-peasy if you are a baker. It comes out very well as long as you don't let it bake too long (it's a delicate cake and will be overdone in like 2 minutes). I take it out when it is almost a little bit underdone and let it sit on a warm stove with a kitchen towel over it to keep the heat in. This lets it cook a bit, gently, and keeps it moist.
I have used a couple different recipes, but I like this one from allrecipes.com very much (it has the real icing and the classic cake):
Red Velvet recipeA fun bit of cake history:
History of Red Velvet CakeOMG, someone put them together and made a red, white, and blue velvet cake!
patriotic velvet cake